Click here to learn about the exhibition of winning projects from this Call for Ideas.
On the occasion of the two hundredth anniversary of the 1811 Commissioners’ Plan for New York, the foundational document that established the Manhattan street plan from Houston Street to 155th Street, the Architectural League invites architects, landscape architects, urban designers, and other design professionals to use the Manhattan street grid as a catalyst for thinking about the present and future of New York. For two centuries, the Manhattan street grid has demonstrated an astonishing flexibility to accommodate the architectural gestures and urban planning theories of successive generations of architects, urban designers, private developers, and city officials. Given its capacity for reinvention, how might the Manhattan grid continue to adapt and respond to the challenges and opportunities–both large and small–that New York faces now and into the future?
The deadline for this call for ideas was September 26. We are no longer accepting entries.
In 1807, frustrated by years of uncontrolled development and a decade of public health epidemics attributed to lower Manhattan’s cramped and irregular streets, New York City’s Common Council (the predecessor to today’s City Council) petitioned the State Legislature to develop a street plan for Manhattan above Houston Street, at that time a rural area of streams and hills populated by a patchwork of country estates, farms, and small houses. The adoption in 1811 of the Commissioners’ Plan for New York laid out in a single bold stroke the Manhattan street plan up to 155th Street (leaving the area north of there for future planners to address). Though it would take the rest of the 19th century to build, this gridiron of twelve north-south avenues and 155 east-west streets would fundamentally shape the future of New York and become an emblem of the city itself.
In celebration of the two hundredth anniversary of the Commissioners’ Plan, the Museum of the City of New York will present The Greatest Grid: The Master Plan of Manhattan, a major exhibition curated by Hilary Ballon that traces the origins and evolution of the grid over two hundred years. As inevitable–or perhaps invisible–as it may seem to New Yorkers today, the Manhattan street plan was an act of breathtaking vision and ambition on the part of city officials and citizens alike, one that required the mobilization of vast resources and decades of sacrifice and inconvenience. Grid plans, of course, were not new; Annapolis, Philadelphia, and Savannah, to name just a few colonial examples, all used a grid in one form or another. What was notable about the Commissioners’ Plan was the relentlessness with which the grid was deployed: 2,028 seemingly identical blocks with little provision for public space and none of the expressive urban gestures then fashionable among city planners–the “circles, ovals, and stars” that, in the commissioners’ own words, “certainly embellish a plan” notwithstanding “their effect as to convenience and utility.” Moreover, the plan displayed a complete disregard for the existing topography of Manhattan, transforming what had been an island of hills, valleys, and streams into the (relatively) level plane necessitated by the straight lines of the plan’s streets and avenues.
Alternately vilified and celebrated over its two hundred years, the Manhattan grid has nonetheless demonstrated a remarkable flexibility to accommodate the architectural gestures and urban planning theories of successive generations of architects, urban designers, private developers, and city officials. Central Park and the super-block housing developments of 1960s urban renewal; Broadway and Madison and Lexington Avenues; the automobile and the subway; the skyscraper and the sliver building; the water system and the electricity grid; zoning resolutions and preservation districts–these are just some of the amendments and additions that the Commissioners’ Plan has accommodated since 1811. Given the grid’s capacity for reinvention, how might it continue to adapt and respond to the challenges and opportunities–both large and small–that New York faces now and into the future?
The Architectural League announces an international Call for Ideas that invites architects, landscape architects, urban designers, and other design professionals to use the Manhattan street grid as a catalyst for thinking about the present and future New York. The League will select up to ten proposals for an exhibition that will be presented at the Museum of the City of New York beginning in December 2011, concurrently with The Greatest Grid: The Master Plan of Manhattan.
What challenges and possibilities face the city today and how might innovative solutions emerge out of (and in turn modify) the existing street grid? We are already seeing new approaches to street use in the Bloomberg Administration’s bike lanes and pedestrian plazas. What other possibilities exist for rethinking streets that might either increase public space or encourage new kinds of uses? What new infrastructures will the city require–or what existing infrastructures might be rethought–and what impact will they have on the grid? How might responsive technologies interact with the grid to imbue it with a radically new kind of adaptability, one that changes from morning to night, or day to day? Are there ways to make more dynamic connections among the different layers of Manhattan, from the subway to the street to the tower? How can blocks be reconfigured to impact density levels or generate new building typologies? What ways can we use New York’s existing topography to better address climate change and sea level rise? Alternatively, what small-scale interventions or insertions might positively impact a single block or neighborhood? At a moment when the city’s economic and demographic diversity are under threat, how could actions on and within the grid work towards counteracting the prevailing forces that are transforming Manhattan into a pleasure ground for the rich and a tourist mecca?
Drawing on the grid’s enduring power as muse and metaphor, the League invites architects and designers to consider how the grid might provide the intellectual and creative framework for thinking about new possibilities and directions. Two hundred years ago, the Commissioners’ Plan was an act of astonishing ambition. What kinds of equally bold, visionary ideas and plans should New York undertake to sustain itself as a world capital–and what trace will they leave on the street grid?
The goal of the project is to propose new ways for thinking about how the street grid shapes life in New York, speculate on how it could continue to accommodate and respond to any number of urban imperatives, and, most importantly, to acknowledge and celebrate the fundamental contributions the Commissioners’ Plan has made to defining New York’s character and identity.
The League welcomes a range of proposals, from the visionary to the practical, large scale or small. Proposals may imagine new configurations of the elements that compose the grid (super block, block, lot, intersection, street, sidewalk, etc.); propose small scale insertions; suggest new building typologies or public spaces; consider the grid’s role as a node in a regional or global network; among other possibilities. Participants are welcome to focus their projects on a specific site or to address the grid as a whole. Given that the exhibition is organized to celebrate the anniversary of the Commissioners’ Plan, some part of the proposal must fall within the area of the 1811 grid (Houston to 155th Street, from river to river). Entrants may participate as either individuals or teams, but no one may submit more than one proposal.
All entrants should submit the following:
•A Cover Sheet (PDF format), with the project title and the names and email addresses of all team members, with one team member designated as the primary contact. The donation ID (see below) for your entry fee should be included on the cover sheet.
•A Design Statement (PDF format) of no more than five hundred words that describes the project. (The cover sheet and the design statement may be one document.)
•A Design Proposal, a high-resolution (300 dpi) PDF of two pages of 24” h x 36” w (landscape format). Submissions may include process drawings, photos, maps, plans, sections, perspectives, and other visual imagery, but all submissions should include at least one view that incorporates or is based on the Manhattan street grid. Please note that depending on final exhibition requirements, some entrants may be asked to reformat their submissions for size and orientation.
There is a required entry fee of $25 per submission. Entrants should pay the fee online here, after which an automatic receipt will be emailed to entrants with a transaction ID. Please include transaction ID on the cover sheet for your submission.
This Call for Ideas is open to all architects, urban designers, landscape architects, and all other design professionals. Students are ineligible for participation.
All submissions must be emailed via yousendit or comparable file sharing service to firstname.lastname@example.org no later than 11:59 p.m. on September 26, 2011. Please put the project title in the subject line.
SELECTION AND AWARDS
Up to ten submissions will be chosen by the jury for exhibition at the Museum of the City of New York. The selected teams will receive an honorarium of $1,000 each. Winners will be announced in mid-October. The exhibition will open in early December.
Amale Andraos, WORKac
Hilary Ballon, Curator, The Greatest Grid: The Master Plan of Manhattan
Sarah Henry, Chief Curator, Museum of the City of New York
Wendy Evans Joseph, Exhibition Designer, The Greatest Grid; Cooper Joseph Studio
Marc Kushner, HWKN; CEO, Architizer
Mark Robbins, Dean, Syracuse University School of Architecture
Bernard Tschumi, Bernard Tschumi Architects
Annabelle Selldorf, President, The Architectural League; Annabelle Selldorf Architects
Gregory Wessner, Curator, The Greatest Grid: Call for Ideas; Digital Programs and Exhibitions Director, The Architectural League
Sarah Whiting, Dean, Rice University School of Architecture
Click on the links below for articles and resources about the Commissioners’ Plan.
“The Greatest Grid: The New York Plan of 1811,” Edward Spann in Two Centuries of American Planning, ed. Daniel Scheffer (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, l988), pp. 11-40 [Link not available]
Click here to read responses to frequently asked questions. All entrants are responsible for revised information in the FAQs. If you have additional questions, please email Gregory Wessner at email@example.com.
The Greatest Grid: A Call for Ideas is organized by the Architectural League of New York and curated by Gregory Wessner. Funding has been provided by the J. Clawson Mills Fund of the Architectural League. League programs are also made possible in part by the New York State Council on the Arts, a State Agency, and the New York City Department of Cultural Affairs in partnership with the City Council.
The Greatest Grid: The Master Plan of Manhattan is organized by the Museum of the City of New York and curated by Hilary Ballon.
The Greatest Grid: The Master Plan of Manhattan is made possible, in part, by the generous support of The Dyson Foundation, ConEdison, The Durst Organization, Lily Auchincloss Foundation, Todd De Garmo, Jill and John Chalsty, Nixon Peabody, Ronay and Richard Menschel, and Vornado Realty Trust.
Additional support is provided by the 42nd Street Development Corporation, Peter Jay Sharp Foundation, Structure Tone, Gardiner & Theobald, American Continental Group, AvalonBay Communities, Benchmark Builders, Robert Derector Associates, VVA Project Managers and Consultants, and Pelli Clarke Pelli Architects.
Architizer is the revolutionary platform for architecture on the internet. An open network of architects, firms, fans, and projects, Architizer has created a database that spans the world in scope. Launched in November 2009, the site now contains the work of 6,400 international firms and 30,000 individuals joining over 300,000 active users on Facebook.